A stock count comes up short, and it is tempting to call the difference “theft” or apply a familiar industry shrink percentage. Neither conclusion is safe without more information. A gap between a stock record and a physical count can come from damage, a receiving error, an unrecorded move, a counting mistake, theft, or several causes at once. For a small stockroom, the useful goal is to find and track the causes you can verify—not to match a national retailer’s number.

What inventory shrink measures

Retailers use “shrink” or “shrinkage” for inventory loss measured by comparing recorded stock with stock physically on hand. The National Retail Federation notes that the measure can include theft, but also administrative mistakes, damaged goods, expired products, and spoilage. Definitions and calculation methods can differ between businesses, so a shrink figure is meaningful only when you know what was counted and how it was calculated. NRF’s explanation of shrink is a useful reminder that the number is not a direct measure of theft.

What the recent benchmarks do—and don’t—say

The NRF and Loss Prevention Research Council’s 2025 Impact of Theft & Violence survey gathered responses from 70 retail companies representing 168 brands. Respondents reported an 18% increase in the average number of shoplifting incidents in 2024 compared with 2023. That is a reported change in shoplifting incidents among survey respondents—not an 18% increase in inventory shrink, and not a forecast for an independent shop or small warehouse.

The sample also skews toward large retailers: NRF reported that the participating brands represented $1.3 trillion in 2024 sales, while 63% of respondents had more than 10,000 employees and 56% operated at least 500 stores. Those details matter. A multi-location retailer’s security procedures, item mix, reporting systems, and exposure are different from a contractor’s parts room or a neighborhood shop’s backroom.

Another often-quoted figure is NRF’s 1.6% average shrink rate for fiscal year 2022, reported in its 2023 National Retail Security Survey, which drew on 177 retail brands. Treat it as a historical result from that survey—not a current target. NRF later explained that it stopped publishing one universal average shrink rate because retail environments and calculation approaches vary. You can review the 2023 survey summary alongside NRF’s explanation of why one average can mislead.

Build a small-business measure you can repeat

Instead of comparing unlike businesses, choose a clear counting period, a defined group of items, and one consistent basis for comparison. For example, an owner might count a selected set of stockroom items at cost and compare the physical count with the recorded quantity at the same cost. If the records show $25,000 of stock and the verified physical count is $24,700, the unexplained difference is $300, or 1.2% of that recorded value. These figures are illustrative only. The percentage is an internal trend for that defined count, not an industry benchmark, and it should not be compared with a retailer’s published shrink rate unless the definitions truly match.

Before calling the full $300 a loss, investigate it. Suppose the team finds $120 of documented damage, an $80 receiving shortage that still needs supplier follow-up, and $100 that remains unexplained after a recount and record check. Keep those categories separate. The first two have possible explanations but may require different next steps; the last is still unknown, not proof of theft. A simple log can record the item, expected and counted quantity, unit or cost basis, location, count date, likely cause, evidence, owner, and resolution.

A five-step shrink self-audit

  1. Set the rules. Choose the period, items or locations in scope, and measurement basis. Use the same rules from count to count so changes are interpretable.
  2. Count and verify. Recount surprising differences before changing records. Check item variants, units, nearby shelves, and recent stock movements.
  3. Assign a cause only when supported. Separate damage or spoilage, receiving differences, data-entry or movement errors, and unknown variance. Use an “unknown” category rather than guessing.
  4. Keep evidence and follow-up together. Save dated count notes, relevant receiving paperwork, and condition or disposition notes. Record who will follow up and by when.
  5. Reconcile after review. Make an operational stock-list correction only after the count and cause have been checked, and keep a record of the change. Review patterns over several periods rather than reacting to one unusual count.

Receiving checks and cycle counts are useful parts of this process, but they answer different questions: receiving checks help catch delivery discrepancies when stock arrives; cycle counts help find differences already in the records. For those routines, see the small warehouse receiving checklist and the guide to cycle counting in a small stockroom.

Keep operational counting separate from tax or financial reporting decisions. The IRS’s Publication 538 discusses accounting periods, methods, and inventory rules; it does not make one simple stockroom percentage suitable for every business. Ask a qualified tax professional or bookkeeper how a particular discrepancy should be treated in your records.

A repeatable, well-documented count is more useful than a dramatic but poorly matched benchmark. If you are comparing inventory tools, review Ququ’s current overview and confirm its present capabilities against your needs; the counting, investigation, and evidence practices above are general operating guidance.